India Slams UN Report On Kashmir, Calls It 'selective Compilation Of Largely Unverified Information'

Releasing its first-ever report by the UN on the human rights situation in Kashmir on either side of the Line of Control (LoC), the Office of the High Commissioner of Human Rights (OHCHR), Zeid Ra'ad Al Hussein, "called on Indian security forces to exercise maximum restraint, and strictly abide by international standards governing the use of force when dealing with future protests, including ones that could well occur this coming weekend." "It is essential the Indian authorities take immediate and effective steps to avoid a repetition of the numerous examples of excessive use of force by security forces in Kashmir," Zeid said.

In an angry response which showed India had been caught off-guard, the MEA spokesperson described the report as "fallacious, tendentious and motivated", violating Indian sovereignty and "a selective compilation of largely unverified information ... overtly prejudiced and seeks to build a false narrative." The report comes at a time when a ceasefire prevails in J&K during the Ramzan period, and some people here see it as a pressure tactic against the Indian government.


The report is a sort of a last hurrah by Al Hussein, who completes his tenure this year and the UN General Assembly will appoint a new chief. Neither India nor Pakistan allowed the OHCHR office access to Kashmir, so Hussein said the report was a result of "remote monitoring". India has an active presence at the UN office in Geneva, but its diplomats failed to pre-empt such a damaging report. However, MEA said it has "conveyed unequivocally" its protest to the OHCHR.

Dilip Sinha, former vice-president to UN Human Rights Council said, "This is a mischievous report because it comes from the obsession with Kashmir by the OIC. This is a case of slamming a country which provides rights to its people and allows NGOs and media to operate, whereas, in Pakistan, they describe the "problem" as more "structural in nature" and lets the country off!"

Despite Indian protests, the report is very damaging in image terms for India. While no member state has asked for any such report to be commissioned, the fact is, the OHCHR actually does function in an autonomous manner. It comes at a time when India is not even on the UN Human Rights Council. Sources said the report had been sent to the UN General Assembly and the UN Security Council.

The report, unfortunately, provides any country with a grouse against India to run with this and call for a resolution or an inquiry. While the chances of this going through are very slim, it does mean that Indian diplomats in different capitals and in the UN headquarters will have to work extra hard to eliminate such possibilities, which actually raises the costs of diplomatic capital.

Source :

India slams UN report on Kashmir, calls it 'selective compilation of largely unverified information'
India slams UN report on Kashmir
India rejects UN rights body report on Kashmir, calls it 'fallacious, motivated'
UN Report on Jammu and Kashmir: Congress Backs Govt’s Stand, Terms it ‘Prejudiced’; Pakistan Welcomes Probe Proposal
India rejects UN report on human rights violation in Kashmir as fallacious
The OHCHR report on Kashmir: Will India succeed in blocking discussions on the report in Geneva?
Up to members to act on rights chief’s call for action on Kashmir: UN spokesperson
Pakistani Islamist lobbied with author of UN report on Kashmir
UN rights office calls for international probe in Kashmir